Home PageFacebookRSS News Feed
PocketGPS
Web
Read the current newsletter! Weekly
Newsletter
SatNav,GPS,Navigation
Get Speed Camera Warnings For SatNavs Get Speed Camera Warnings For Android Get Speed Camera Warnings For iPhone
TomTom Palm Speed Camera POIs 5th October 2004

TomTom GPS productsArticle by Mike Barrett

 

TomTom are releasing a new version of software for the TomTom Navigator for Palm GPS navigation system. This contains quite a few new features, amongst them are travel vias, avoid roads and some other useful additions. The most important (as far as we at PocketGPSWorld.com are concerned) is the implementation of customisable POIs.

TomTom navigator for palm POIs

 

This means that the popular PocketGPSWorld.com Speed (sorry safety) Camera database can now be used. Ah (I hear you say) but what about the 3rd party warning add-ins so I can be warned about approaching a POI? Well you don't need them any more TomTom Navigator for Palm now has a built in POI proximity warning system.

 

Back in June I went out to dinner with Harold Goddijn (TomTom CEO), Peter-Frans Pauwels ( TomTom CTO) and Mark Gretton (TomTom Programme Director) where we had an in depth discussion about POIs and detection, with particular emphasis on the reasons the UK are so interested in it. They told me there were some developments underway. Sure enough a few weeks later I was beta testing a built in POI system including a POI warner.

 

I started using this software back in the early Summer just as I went on holiday to Phoenix, Arizona. The initial software I had didn't work very well, in fact it actually crashed. Fortunately I had taken my laptop with me and could download updates while I was out there.

 

This is the same software that was originally intended for the UK launch of TomTom GO, but as usual with software the schedules were not quite met. I for one would rather have properly debugged software rather than a quick release and numerous patch releases.

 

The software is complete with with a full POI database management interface and a rudimentary warning system when you approach a POI.

 

TomTom GPS navigation POI warningThe picture to the right above shows the TomTom Navigator for Palm in action with the active speed camera in the background. You can just about make out the POI warning icons both on the route and positioned in the top left hand corner.

 

The picture to the right shows the entire range TomTom navigation products using the 'common navigation engine' with the new POI system working. And yes my windscreen really is that dirty.

 

Below is a brief tour of the TomTom Navigator for Palm POI system. I have extensively used it with our PocketGPSWorld.com Speed Camera POI database and can confirm that despite a few small niggles it works really well.

 

TomTom Navigator for Palm customisable POIs

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed cameraThe picture to the right shows what some graffiti artist dubbed as "Fine City". This is the string of operational speed cameras which now decorate the side of the A127 between Eastwood and Southend town centre.

 

For some strange reason the council seem to prefer planting cameras rather than trees nowadays.

 

Anyway, as we know, there are many people out there who wish to know where these modern day objects of un-natural beauty are located. To assist all these lovers of the devices we started collating a POI database two years or so ago.

 

This proved very popular with users of TomTom 2 and 3. The recently release TomTom GO is now seeing a huge amount of interest in this feature as well. And now finally the Palm software is getting the customisable POI databases.

 

When TomTom released the Palm version of Navigator there was a shocked gasp! The new software did not support custom POIs.

 

It therefore did not allow the PocketGPSWorld.com camera database, or any of our other POI databases to be used.

 

This was compounded with the release of TomTom GO. Again no customisable POIs, no speed camera detection. There was a mention of this being available for the UK release, but it missed the deadline and the new GOs didn't have this functionality.

 

Well TomTom have made amends and released the new Palm software, here is a quick tour of the new POI features.

 

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera
Maintaining TomTom Navigator for Palm POIs

As mentioned above TomTom Navigator for Palm has a full POI management interface. This will be displayed as an icon on the second screen of the "Change Preferences" display. This allows you to:

  • Add new POI databases
  • Delete POI Databases
  • Add POIs
  • Delete POIs
  • Enable the display of POI categories
  • Warn when you are near a POI

User customisable POI databases are arranged in files (with an ov2 extension) these also come with a graphic .bmp file. Both must have the same name to work together.

 

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

The databases do not need to be created on the Palm device they can be imported from a number of sources, including PocketGPSWorld.com

 

All you need to do to import them is to copy the .ov2 and .bmp into the map directory on the Palm. In the case of the UK this will be "Great Britain Navigator". It will be different for other countries.

 

The POI files are compatible with all previous versions of POI files for TomTom Navigator. They are also interchangeable with TomTom GO and the recently announced TomTom Mobile.

 

The main POI maintenance screen is shown to the right. From here you can manage all the features of the POIs.

 

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

Adding a POI Category.

 

A POI category is an ov2 database. To create your own personalised category all you need to do is to tap the "Add POI Category" icon and then follow the screens through.

 

The first screen names the category. I prefer to use POI files rather then favourites to store information about my friends, relations, and business addresses.

 

This allows me to share the databases between my devices TomTom 3, TomTom for Palm, TomTom GO and TomTom Mobile. It also allows me to share certain databases with friends and workmates.

 

The example screens to the right show me creating a new database called Mates.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

 

The next screen displayed is that to the immediate right. This lets you select an icon to be associated with the POI database.

 

TomTom provide a number of images, ranging from somewhat boring dots, through to some interesting graphics.

 

I chose a pair of ruby red lips. Well nobody said I had any taste did they?

 

You can also create your own graphic. The restrictions are that it must be 256 colour 8 bit .bmp format file. If it is not then it can cause TomTom Navigator to crash.

 

You have been warned!!!

 

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera
Adding a custom POI to the TomTom Navigator for Palm

Adding a new custom POI to one of the POI databases is straightforward and easy. One drawback is that the process involves at least 8 taps of the screen so is not advisable whilst driving.

 

To add the new POI you tap on the "Add POI" icon on the POI preferences screen.

 

This will then prompt you to select a category for your new POI. The display will only show the customisable POIs, as you cannot modify any of the built-in databases.

 

As I was recording the location of my return depot for the rental car I selected the "Holiday" category.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

Once a category has been chosen you must then define where the POI is. To do this you are presented with the normal location selection screen.

 

Now at first it may seem a little dumb allowing you to add your home location as a POI, but if you know a lot of people with TomTom as I do then this is an ideal way of sending your GPS location to your contacts. All you need to do is create a new POI database then add one POI as home and save it from the Palm to your PC then all you need to do is email the files to your friends with TomTom.

 

The most usual option taken here is probably going to be the GPS position. This simply records your current location.

 

I mentioned earlier that you cannot modify the built-in POIs. This doesn't stop you adding a built in POI to your database. Simply select "Point of Interest" and then finding the one you are wanting to add.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

 

Once you have selected your location you have to name it. By default the name associated with the selected location is displayed. This is not much use if it just says "Home" or "Abc Road" so you need to change it to something more useful.

 

Remember to make it meaningful as you may not refer back to it for some time and probably will forget (like I do) what the POI was. My worst nightmare is trying to return a rental car, particularly in America. All you need to do is mark the position of the return as you leave the rental depot and it makes it easy to get back there.

 

That is unless you do as we did... Ignore the Sat Nav and follow the written instructions (but reading them the wrong way round). Good thing my wife doesn't read this site!!

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera
Warning when approaching a POI

The TomTom Navigator for Palm software has a POI warning system integrated into the software. This can be activated individually for each different POI database or category.

 

This is configured or changed by selecting the "Warn when near POI" from the Maintain POI menu screen. This displays the POI database selection screen shown to the right.

 

If you already have some POI databases that are set to issue warnings then these will be displayed first with a small speaker icon to the left. I have selected "H" to select the Holiday category. As you can see the speaker icon to the left this signifies that the proximity warnings warnings have already been configured.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

Tap on the category to select it and you will be moved on to the next screen. This is where you select the distance that you will be warned at.

 

The default for me seemed to be 273 yards. A most obvious default...

 

Actually I suppose that it may actually be something quite sensible in meters, but I couldn't be bothered to reset the system to metric to find out.

 

OK... Having written that it niggled at me and I gave in and reset my system to metric. Of course 273 yards is 250 meters. That reminded me why I prefer to play golf in the UK or America. 275 yards sounds much further than 250 meters doesn't it?

 

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

Anyway once you have selected the distance you want to be warned at you move on to select the sound you want to have warn you.

 

There is a range of 15 sounds that you can have played ranging from bells and beeps to a bugle and a cukoo (TomTom's spelling not mine). These are pretty limited, but they do have the desired effect of catching your attention.

 

You can set different sounds for different POI databases, so you can have a range of alerts blasting your ear drums as you approach these POIs.

 

At the moment there is no capability to have your own sound file played. This is one request I made to TomTom during the beta test. I doesn't look as if we can do this at the moment.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

 

The next screen was a complete shock. A tick box so that you are only warned if the POI is on your route.

 

So what is this all about? Warning if POI is on route? How does this work?

 

The best way to describe this is to let the TomTom CTO define his design criteria:

 

The POI warner is made with lots of uses in mind, not just speed camera's.
In fact, we started out with two simple use cases:

(1) my brother always wants to be warned when there is an opportunity to tank Texaco. He has a database of Texaco stations, and wants advance warnings of a few miles. However, he is not prepared to get off the road to do it. He is also NOT interested in gas stations on the other side of the road.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

He would therefor checkmark the "on-route" box.


HOWEVER, note that gas stations aren't actually ON the highway, but usually on a off/on ramp - the software will therefor consider something that is either on the route, or can be reached by driving at most a few hundred yards a gas station is still considered to be "on-route"

(2) my wife wants to be warned if she is within a few miles of a museum. It doesn't have to be on her route, she is quite prepared to drive a few miles extra.

So:

(1) if the on-route is set, only POI that are on your route, on YOUR side of the road, are included;
And "on route" means every point on the route AND every point that is connected by less than 250 yards of paving.

(2) whether set or not, only POI that are "ahead" of you (up to 90 degrees left and right) are included in the warnings.

 

Enabling and Disabling POIs

 

This option allows you to determine which POIs are shown on the Map and Navigator displays. This works with both built in and custom POIs.

 

It is a very simple interface. To the left of the POI database category is a tick box. If it is ticked then the POI will be shown on the map or navigator display. If it is unchecked it will not. Again the currently displayed POI categories are listed first, then the non-displayed.

 

To the bottom right you can see a keyboard icon. If you tap on this then the keyboard is displayed you can tap-type your category.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

Deleting a POI

 

You can only delete user customisable POIs. When you tap the "Delete POI" icon you are shown the list of installed POI databases.

 

The screen shot on the right shows my custom POI databases.

 

To select the POI database simply tap on the one you want. If you have a large number of installed POI files then you can get the keyboard up to filter the selection.

 

Interestingly I haven't worked out how to get rid of the keyboard once selected.

 

 

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

I had inadvertently added a POI intended for the Mates POI database into the PocketGPSWorld.com Speed Camera POI database. This had to be removed otherwise if I sent these to the site for update we would get a false camera recorded.

 

As I had realised my mistake at the time I hit the delete button quickly. A useful feature of the software is that it uses the GPS position and will display POIs ranging away from your current position.

 

Look at that! No less than 6 cameras within about 2 miles of my friends house. We are popular in this little corner of Essex.

 

Once the POI to be deleted has been selected you are requested to confirm the deletion.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

A very sensible display to have. I couldn't count the number of times my fat little fingers have missed the item I wanted to select. Which was how it got in this category in the first place! So having confirmation is great.

 

A quick tap on yes and the offending POI has gone. Then back to the Add POI and put it in the proper POI database this time.

 

Of course I could have used the POI facility in the Add POI section to copy it into the correct database before deleting it. Logical thought patterns always fail when I need them.

 

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera
TomTom Navigator for Palm POIs in use

Having played around with the TomTom Navigator POI system for some time I am quite impressed. Sure it doesn't have the full feature set of the TomTom 3 third party add-on POI warners, but it works and it works well.

 

TomTom made the right decision to retain compatibility with their POI database format for other GPS products ensuring that there is a full range of POIs available from the release of the software.

 

Without using the warning features of the software the user customisable POIs work in exactly the same way as built-in POIs. Of course the big advantage is that you can now sit down and create a database of all the Train spotting locations, (sorry lads).

 

More usefully for the rest of us we can use the facilities of the PocketGPSWorld.com speed camera database. This is a resource available for download from our site.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

 

When you combine this with the warning facilities built in to the TomTom Navigator for Palm software you now have a fully legal (did I really put that in writing?) passive safety system warning you of well known accident blackspots. Well they must be otherwise they wouldn't be putting the cameras there would they?

 

So how does it work? Well as you come within range of the POI a sound is emitted. Even if your voice instructions are switched off the sound will play.

 

Apart from the sound there is a visual indication provided in the top left corner of the screen. This shows the POI type detected, and the distance in yards or meters to the POI.

 

A further indication is made by flashing a red border of the POI icon on the screen.

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera

 

A feature of the software I tested was the POI being "on route". I did find this a problem with some POIs.

 

The reason for this is that when traveling down a dual carriageway the POI is recorded from the other side of the road, or in some cases where there are 2 cameras on opposite sides of the road the database only has one recorded.

 

Why would this matter? Well TomTom checks the route for POIs in the case where the POI is recorded and showing on the wrong side of the carriageway then it is deemed not to be on route. i.e. more than the warning distance away. Therefore you are not warned. This didn't happen very often, but is a cause for concern.

 

Another example of failed warnings is when the POI is recorded a distance from the road. Again the software does not see this as being "on route"

 

This is not a fault with the TomTom software, more the accuracy of the POI database in use. This can be easily overcome by removing the "warn on route" setting.

 

TomTom Navigator for Palm custom POI speed camera
Conclusions  

Well it is another free upgrade to TomTom Navigator for Palm so it is a no-brainer anyway. I think that TomTom have added a good feature set to the new Common Navigation Platform software suite. It doesn't have the full functionality of the third party add-ons for TomTom Navigator 3, but it does include the "warn only on route" feature.

 

I would have preferred to have a one (or two) tap option for recording a POI to enable capture of locations whilst driving past them. I can see the point of the numerous steps, but a simple tap-tap to record to a default POI database would have been good. Maybe next release? This is of course showing my paranoia for the UK fascination with speed cameras, and the customisable POIs have many other benefits.

Pros

  • Adds crucial missing functionality
  • It's free!!
  • On route POI detection
  • Vast range of POI databases
  • Works with PocketGPSWorld.com camera database.
  • Cross platform compatability

Cons

  • Limited functionality (compared to third party add-ons)
  • Warning sounds are not user definable (cannot use your own sound files)
  • The "on route" warning can not warn if the POI is not accurately positioned.

 

Resources

Where do you get your POI databases from, where are the tools to manipulate them?

 

Answering the second question first the manipulation of the POIs can be done within TomTom itself. If you want to convert from one location format to another it can get a bit tricky, but there are tools available to help you. One of the first places to look is in our downloads section.

 

TomTom provide details and some tools on their web site.

 

The POI databases are available from a number of sources. I have listed some here. If you know of some good sources that are not included please email me and we can add them to this list.

 

 

Site Comments
PocketGPSWorld.com Our UK Speed Camera POI database
PocketGPSWorld.com Our main TomTom POI section on the site. Here we have a wide range of POI databases ranging from bird sanctuaries and Nature reserves to Castles and many other useful categories, from many different countries.
tomtom.com The POI pages on the TomTom web site
tomtom.com The POI databases that TomTom publishes.
Gpspassion.com French "Dangerous Roads", cheap petrol stations, Hotel and Restaurant chains etc POI database downloads

 

If you have POIs that you want to submit to us for inclusion on our site please email them to reviews@pocketgpsworld.com . We reserve the right to review the content before deciding to publish.

 

Review equipment provided by:

 

TotalPDA

 

 

Comments ?

Have any comments about this review ? Post them here.

CamerAlert Apps



iOS QR Code






Android QR Code







Terms & Privacy

GPS Shopping