Home PageFacebookRSS News Feed
PocketGPS
Web
Read the current newsletter! Weekly
Newsletter
SatNav,GPS,Navigation

 

Reviewed: Garmin nuvi 30

 

Reviewed By

Matthew (MaFt) Morley

Review Date

21st August 2012

Manufacturer

Garmin UK

RRP

£79.99 inc VAT

9

 

I think it’s safe to say that the majority are struggling financially at the moment and, while interesting to read, there’s not much point reviewing top-of-the-range, flagship devices. Especially when probably 90% of the audience aren’t in a position to splash out on such items. It was for this very reason that we asked Garmin for a nuvi 30 to review - as part of their Essential Range, this is their most basic, entry-level personal navigation device (PND). With an RRP of £79.99 it is certainly more affordable than their £279.99 nuvi 3590LMT.

 

So, just what do you get for your £80? Just how ‘basic’ is their entry-level nuvi 30? Well, to be honest my first impressions were very good and I’ll admit I was genuinely surprised at how many features had been included in this budget PND. It has Text-to-Speech (TTS) so road names are read out to you in full; it has Lane Guidance so on motorways and other large roads you know which lane to get into; it has Junction View so you can get a photo-realistic view of the junction ahead; it displays the current road speed limit; it has the latest NAVTEQ mapping (2012.10); it has a micro SD slot for map updates; and it also has the Cyclops speed camera database (although our own CamerAlert database can be installed easily) and millions of POIs for shops, restaurants, airports etc (again our POIs can be easily installed too).

 


What's in the box?

 

It’s par for the course these days that no USB lead is included, there’s also no instruction manual. However, you do get the windscreen mount, power lead and a basic quickstart guide.

 


Main menus: normal (left), during navigation (right)

 

Set up is simple and the satellite fix from a cold start was certainly fast enough. The nuvi 30 uses Garmin’s tried and trusted simple menu with 2 main options of “Where To?” and “View Map”. You can also access the settings from the main menu too. When you have a route set you get extra options on the main menu for generating an alternative route or for stopping navigation.

 

I thought I’d give it an easy route to begin with so I used it to take us on the 365 mile journey from Bradford to Newquay. Route calculation for such a long journey was done without much delay and it wasn’t long until we were off. The route was sensible and matched what we would have driven anyway. When we stopped at Exeter we decided we would head to a Tesco to stock up on a few essential items (beer, crisps, milk) so I tapped on “Where To?” then selected “Near” at the bottom of the screen. From here I could choose to search near certain places including my destination, my current location and another city. Searching for Points of Interest was nice and easy, I selected Shopping and then Grocery Stores (under which Supermarkets are included).

 


Search for POIs

 

I found a Tesco in Saint Austell that wasn’t too far off our route and tapped “Go”. I was then given the option of making that my destination or adding it as a via point. The nuvi 30, as with most of the lower-end Garmin models, only offers a single via point. It was when we arrived that I realised the POI data was actually fairly inaccurate. It took us to a road and proudly declared that we had reached Tesco; in fact it was no where to be seen... So I took a guess and carried on driving and after about 200m I could see the top of a Tesco petrol station so headed towards that and eventually found it. The images below show the difference between the Garmin (or rather NAVTEQ) data and the actual location.

 


Poor POI accuracy

 

This wasn’t an isolated incident though, I’ve always had issues with the accuracy of the bundled points of interest in both NAVTEQ and TomTom (formerly TeleAtlas) mapping. Another incident with POIs was in Hayle where we were meeting friends at The Loggans Moor which is a Brewers Fayre pub. We’ve been here a few times so I knew where it was roughly but searching for ‘Loggans Moor’ under Restaurants gave no results as did ‘Brewers Fayre’. After this I searched ‘Near another city’, selected ‘Hayle’ then ‘Restaraunts’ and scrolled down the list. I found an entry under ‘Brewsters’ (which were phased out and rebranded as ‘Brewers Fayre’ way back in 2005) and had a look at the map. Again the accuracy was very poor but, as I knew I could find the real location from here I tapped on ‘Go’. Again, the map below shows the difference between the NAVTEQ location and the real location. Had I not known where I was actually going then I would likely have been rather frustrated with the nuvi 30.

 


Poor POI accuracy (again)

 

Other destinations available under the ‘Where To’ option include address, points of interest, home, recent destinations, favourites and coordinates. Coordinates can be entered in a variety of formats and the address search also includes full 7-digit UK postcodes. Navigation options (Main menu, settings, navigation) include route preferences of faster time, shorter distance and off-road. Off-road gives you a direct point-to-point route so could be useful for finding a specific set of coordinates without necessarily driving there. You can also set avoidances for u-turns, motorways (finally, they stopped calling them highways!), toll roads, ferries, car share lanes and unpaved roads.

 

While using the nuvi 30 it’s worth pointing out that you can drag your finger to scroll up and down the menus as well as tapping the up/down arrows. Although if you are used to a modern smartphone then you will find that it’s not as responsive due to the type of screen used. If you push down fairly hard (or use a stylus or finger nail) then it does work quite well for scrolling. There is no pinch/pull though for zooming in or out of the map.

 


Main navigation screen (night colours)

 

During navigation the route is highlighted clearly in the usual pink/purple that Garmin have used for years. Even though the nuvi 30 features a relatively small 3.5 inch screen the display is laid out well with concise information and enough screen real estate left for the routing. The bottom left has an arrow (taking you back to the main menu) as well as your arrival time, the bottom right shows your current speed, the top bar shows your next turn and current road and there are also + and - buttons for zooming in and out. The arrival time can be tapped to change what it displays from arrival time, distance, time to destination, direction of travel, elevation or current time.

 


Customising the left-hand display item

 

Tapping the bar at the top takes you to a list of directions for your entire route and then tapping one of these directions gives you a close up map of the junction as well as an estimated time and distance to the junction. If it’s on a motorway (or some other major roads) you can also tap to see the Junction View.

 


Tap the top bar for your route details and junction previews

 

Tapping the bottom right (current speed) takes you to the trip computer where you can see various stats about your journey such as direction, distance to go, top speed, journey time etc.

 


Trip computer

 

 

The nuvi 30 has Lane Assist as well as Junction View. This is a useful driver aid as it shows you which lanes you need to be in to stay on your route, the Junction View is a ‘photo-realistic’ view of the junction, along with signs, so you have an idea of what to expect. I do find this a little bit of a gimmick though (it's a static image that does not show your actual position) but the Lane Assist is very useful.

 


Lane Assist (top left of screen)

 

The built-in speaker is loud and clear even during motorway driving with music on. The nuvi 30 also has Text-to-Speech so road names are spoken - this was a pleasant surprise for an entry-level device as previously Garmin’s entry-level nuvi 200 series lacked this feature. Navigation instructions are given in good time and the countdown to the next junction is nice and clear at the top left of the screen.

 

Some Garmin units, such as the nuLink! 2390 or the nuvi 3790, have been known to offer some slightly odd routes when driving on large A-roads or motorways. Occasionally it will route you off at a junction to go around the roundabout and then come back onto the road you were on previously. I am pleased to say that in the 800 or so miles I’ve done with the nuvi 30 I’ve not had this issue once.

 

The only time the smaller screen size has a detrimental effect (unless you have problems with your eyesight) is with the speed camera alerts. A large chunk of the screen is covered up to the point where it even makes it difficult (sometimes impossible) to see your route, particularly at a complex junction. Note that this is the same with a 3rd party database such as ours.

 


POI (speed camera) alerts taking up too much space and covering up the next turn

 

The overall build quality of the nuvi 30, while pretty much entirely plastic, is very sturdy and well made. The windscreen mount stays attached even in hot weather; older versions used to drop off in the heat when the air behind expanded.

 


Windscreen mount

 

 

All in all the nuvi 30 is actually a very nice PND to use, particularly for the price. If a 3.5 inch screen is a bit small for your liking then you can upgrade to the nuvi 40 which is exactly the same albeit with a 4.3 inch screen and an RRP of £89.99. The nuvi 50 will take it to a 5 inch screen at a reasonable £99.99. It’s packed with useful features and no extra bloat, it’s easy to use and it performs well. I’m happy to give this an outstanding 9/10 when taking the price range into consideration.

 


References

Manufacturers Web site http://www.Garmin.co.uk
Pocket GPS Contributor

Matthew (MaFt) Morley

   
Forum Comments:

 

Comments
Posted by worried on Wed Aug 22, 2012 6:52 am Reply with quote

I have a low end Garmin 2300 and find the way it treats POI very frustrating, but the mapping is very good, just used it for a long trip from Gateshead to Chelmsford, found that it very quickly changes the calculated route if you make a small deviation, usually within 10 seconds.

on the POI, I have your Speed Camera database installed and although they flash up on the screen, I have been unable to get the speech announcement working.

On other installed POI the Garmin treats them badly, if the place is 10 feet off your road it will not display them, I have had to keep my old NAVCON just so that I can see them, (its maps are now four years old and not supported) My local Tesco has its front entrance on the Market place, but the car park entrance is at the back down a side street, if you go past the road to the Market place, it stops navigating and displaying it..


I have been using Tesco in St Austell recently, my one seemed to work OK, perhaps its because I have your Tesco database set up!!


 
Posted by MaFt on Wed Aug 22, 2012 7:19 am Reply with quote

worried Wrote:
on the POI, I have your Speed Camera database installed and although they flash up on the screen, I have been unable to get the speech announcement working.

Have you put 'sox.exe' file in your POILoader software folder?

worried Wrote:
I have been using Tesco in St Austell recently, my one seemed to work OK, perhaps its because I have your Tesco database set up!!

More than likely as we have the correct location in our database. As this was a review of the device out of the box I felt it needed highlighting that the inbuilt POIs were inaccurate as opposed to ignoring that and using ours for the review.

MaFt


MaFt®

 
Posted by M8TJT on Wed Aug 22, 2012 7:55 am Reply with quote

MaFt Wrote:
Especially when probably 90% of the audience aren’t in a position to splash out on such items.
Known fact, statistic, generalisation or wild guess? Very Happy Very Happy Twisted Evil


 
Posted by zebsogo on Wed Aug 22, 2012 12:52 pm Reply with quote

my oh my not another garmin..how many more cheap plastic blocky child like graphics pnd's can Garmin make..rubbish routing too..

I bet you can guess i can't stand Garmin devices


--
Navigon 92 Premium Live, Navigon 72 Plus live and a TomTom Via 120 Live ( For the wife )

 
Posted by TJ63 on Fri Aug 24, 2012 8:11 am Reply with quote

I've been using one of these for a few months now, and it's a very good device - much better than the predecessor 105. The spoken street names feature is very useful, as most of my journeys are short ones on unfamiliar urban roads.

The only real gripe I have with it is that there is no facility to clear the trip log. You can switch it on or off, but can't clear it. Consequently the display near my home/work is full of annoying blue lines. If anyone knows a way to clear it, I'll be very grateful.


TJ


 
Posted by willton on Fri Aug 24, 2012 10:00 am Reply with quote

The link to this review from today's newsletter takes you to the CSR chip debut page

http://www.pocketgpsworld.com/CSR-debuts-first-SiRFstarV-chip-optimised-for-smartphones-8428.php


 
Posted by Gurubarry on Fri Aug 24, 2012 10:29 am Reply with quote

Good sensible review, thanks , very useful . Very Happy


Don't Take Life too Seriously-You'll Never Get Out Alive

 
Posted by Darren on Fri Aug 24, 2012 11:37 am Reply with quote

willton Wrote:
The link to this review from today's newsletter takes you to the CSR chip debut page

http://www.pocketgpsworld.com/CSR-debuts-first-SiRFstarV-chip-optimised-for-smartphones-8428.php

An error on my part, corrected in the on-line version here.


Darren Griffin - Editor

 
Posted by deDion on Mon Aug 27, 2012 7:18 pm Reply with quote

Hi Matthew,
NUVI 30( but also applies to the NUVI 40 and 50 )
Good review, but I am confused because you say the nuvi 30 reviewed by you has the latest Garmin mapping (2012.10) which according to gpsreview.net(Garmin Nuvi Forum) was issued (Wed )May 18th 2011. and the latest map update was issued (Thu) Aug 16th 2012 being (2013.20) i.e FIVE issues later.However please correct me if this information is wrong.
Demo sat nav at Halfords--- Nuvi 50 also appears to contain an outdated map
(2012.10) which many buyers will presume is the latest. [/u]


 
Posted by MaFt on Mon Aug 27, 2012 9:33 pm Reply with quote

Oops, that looks like an error on my part. The device came pre-installed with 2012.10. Because it has the latest map guaruntee you would be entitled to the latest version of the map when you register it, however as it is a review device I can't actually do all that!

Sorry, and hope that makes sense?

MaFt


MaFt®

 
Posted by deDion on Mon Aug 27, 2012 9:58 pm Reply with quote

Thank you for your prompt reply.Yes ! That makes sense,but still strange that Garmin would designate a map update issued May 2011 as (2012.10). Many customers would assume that it was indeed a 2012 map and possibly not bother to register and claim their update.


 
Click here to view more comments...
Reply to topic


CamerAlert Database

Click here for the PocketGPSWorld.com Speed Camera Database

Download CamerAlert Speed Camera Database



WORLDWIDE SPEED CAMERA SPOTTERS WANTED!

Click here to submit camera positions to the PocketGPSWorld.com Speed Camera Database


12mth Subscriber memberships awarded every week for verified new camera reports!

Submit Speed Camera Locations Now


CamerAlert Apps



iOS QR Code






Android QR Code







© Terms & Privacy

GPS Shopping